"Oh, yeah. Hope and Landon are my best friends. They wouldn't make something like this up to mess with me. Plus my dad confirmed some of it, when he was here."

Trusting the veracity of the information is not the problem, at least in Josie's case. In fact, if Landon had realized that she wasn't from the same time period as him, he might not have told her at all. In some ways, she's glad it came out the way it did, because knowing Hell it could have had the potential to be worse.

"But that doesn't make it any more difficult to wrestle with, you know? To know that you had the choice and you made one that got people hurt."

She doesn't know if that's what Jon's been struggling with, but that's definitely hers. Especially some of the people she chose to target.